The Most Underrated Beaches in the Caribbean Right Now

Published on December 2, 2025

by Zephyr Drake

In the midst of the pandemic, travel plans have come to a halt for many of us. However, with the world slowly reopening and vaccinations being rolled out, now is the perfect time to start planning your next tropical getaway. The Caribbean has always been a popular destination for its stunning beaches, crystal clear waters, and luxurious resorts. But with so many well-known beaches, some of the true hidden gems often go unnoticed. That’s why we’ve rounded up the most underrated beaches in the Caribbean right now, so you can escape the crowds and indulge in your own private paradise.The Most Underrated Beaches in the Caribbean Right Now

1. Culebrita Island Beach – Puerto Rico

Nestled in the northeast corner of Puerto Rico, Culebrita Island Beach is a secluded gem that boasts untouched beauty and tranquility. With no development on the island, this beach is perfect for those looking to get off the grid and immerse themselves in nature. The crystal clear waters are perfect for swimming, snorkeling, and even surfing. Don’t forget to hike to the top of the Culebrita Lighthouse for breathtaking views of the surrounding islands.

Pro Tip: Bring your own food and water, as there are no amenities on the island.

2. Pigeon Point – Tobago

Tobago may be a lesser-known Caribbean island, but it’s home to some of the most beautiful beaches in the world. Pigeon Point Beach is a stunning stretch of white sand, turquoise waters, and palm trees swaying in the breeze. The calm waters are perfect for swimming, and there are plenty of water sports to try, including kayaking and paddleboarding. Bonus: this beach is also a popular spot for birdwatching, as the name suggests.

Pro Tip: Visit on a weekday to avoid crowds, as this beach can get busy on weekends.

3. Half Moon Bay Beach – Antigua

With over 365 beaches, it’s no surprise that Antigua has some hidden gems. Half Moon Bay Beach, located on the east coast of the island, offers a peaceful escape from the popular tourist areas. This secluded beach is home to powdery white sand, sparkling blue waters, and stunning cliffs. During low tide, you can even walk out to nearby islands for private picnics and exploring. End your day with a refreshing cocktail and a delicious meal at the nearby beach bar.

Pro Tip: Bring your own beach umbrella, as there is limited shade on this beach.

4. Little Bay Beach – Anguilla

Located on the serene island of Anguilla, Little Bay Beach is a hidden gem that can only be reached by boat or a hike down a steep path. This secluded beach offers privacy and seclusion, making it perfect for couples or those looking for a peaceful escape. The calm waters are ideal for snorkeling, and the towering cliffs offer amazing views of the surrounding area.

Pro Tip: Bring your snorkeling gear and explore the colorful marine life just below the water’s surface.

5. Salt Whistle Bay – Mayreau

If you’re looking for a truly off-the-beaten-path experience, head to Salt Whistle Bay on the small island of Mayreau. This picture-perfect beach can only be reached by boat, but the journey is well worth it. Surrounded by lush green hills, this secluded bay offers calm waters for swimming and snorkeling, as well as plenty of shade under the palm trees. And if you’re lucky, you may even spot a sea turtle or two!

Pro Tip: Visit during low tide to walk along the beach and explore the small island across the bay.

The Caribbean is known for its stunning beaches, but sometimes the most beautiful spots are the ones that are lesser-known. So why not skip the crowded tourist beaches and discover some of the Caribbean’s hidden gems? From secluded coves to pristine stretches of sand, these underrated beaches are waiting to be explored.